YOU NEED A PLAN.
Find your local EAA Flight Adviser and discuss this with him/her. They have a plan to conduct an evaluation of the proposed pilot, AND a very nice set of cards on how to perform a flight test.
One of the greatest complements I received while conducting a first flight was what was overheard by one of the observers.
This was a routine first flight being performed on a LongEZ in Hollister California. I was the pilot and the owner of the plane was acting as the ground observer.
We both had a copy of the test cards (checklist for what we were testing). As I finished each card, I would call him on the radio and advise "Card XYZ complete, no deviations".
A few people from the local skydiving club had gathered and were curious and watching.
One of the spectators was heard to say;
"Wow, you guys are really organized, this is like NASA or something".
Well, we don't have the NASA budget, but we did barrow some of their procedures and plans.
Waiter