8
« on: May 19, 2006, 04:31:29 PM »
I own a Lowrance 1000 and I have owned a Garmin 196 which I sold with my share of a partnership. I haven't the opportunity to fly with it yet(Long Ez is down for some work). I have driven around with it in my car and played with most of the functions while driving. I haven't gotten used them side by side so my comparison to the Garmin are based on my memory of the Garmin.
There are positives and negatives to both the 1000 and 196. The price on the 1000 was my main reason for giving it a try. The larger screen is a big plus but is kind of negated by it's larger pixels then the 196. The smaller screen of the 196 seems clearer and maybe has more shades of gray. I like the way Lowrance did their keys and menus picks better than the Garmin. The picks seem a little more intuitive then the Garmin.
There are a couple of things the Lowrance doesn't have that I miss from the Garmin. When you put your destination into the Garmin it offers you the option to choose the approach proceedures offered at that airport. That's really nice if your using it as an IFR back up. The Lowrance will only offer you a choice of runways and then overlays a graphic icon of an approach arrow to help you line up with the runway centerline. Garmin had a feature that put a vector or line of a certain length from extending out from your position. I thought it was really useful. If you wanted to fly direct to a point on the map it made it easy to place the point you want to fly over under that line. The Lowrance comes with a lot of extras. You get several mounting systems. RAM's mount etc. USB card reader for the memory chip. I believe it is a over the counter type smart chip so that should make it easy to upgrade.
One big negative is I did have my Lowrance fail on me in the short time that I've owned it. They were good about replacing it but still makes me wonder about the quality.
The bottom line is you get what you pay for. If you have the money I would buy the Garmin, but for the price you get quite a lot with the Lowrance.
Hope this helps.